What's wrong with this picture?

Could it be the happy, happy look on the Peep snowman's face, despite impending melting and subsequent consumption?

Or perhaps it's the shit-eating grin on the face the oddly hued (seriously, what color were they going for, dog-pee-in-snow?) Peep gingerbread man with the cinnamon stick shoved firmly up its marshmallow ass.

Or is it the overall "classy" amibience of this holiday platter, which is in direct conflict with the fact that said platter is furnished primarily with Marshmallow Peeps?

It's hard to say for certain, but I'm going to go with "all of the above."